Threads That Bind: The Story Behind Saturday's FA Cup Tie

Cup draws have a habit of creating fascinating storylines.

Local rivalries. Former clubs. Familiar faces.

But every so often, they produce something far richer.

When Blyth Spartans were drawn at home to Newcastle Blue Star in the Emirates FA Cup Extra Preliminary Round, it wasn't simply the beginning of a new season or another local encounter. Instead, it brought together two clubs whose stories have become increasingly intertwined over recent years.

From the dugout to the dressing room, Saturday's tie is shaped by shared histories, familiar faces and the journeys that have connected Croft Park and Scotswood Road.
And while friendships will be renewed before kick-off, only one side will be celebrating come 5pm.


The Architects

The strongest link between the two clubs begins in the technical area.

When Marc Nash and Anthony Woodhouse arrived at Newcastle Blue Star in November 2023, the club was competing in the Northern League Division Two. In less than two years, they transformed the club's fortunes.

Promotion was secured at the first attempt before Blue Star mounted an immediate challenge for back-to-back promotions, eventually falling agonisingly short in the Division One play-off final after a penalty shootout defeat.

Their success wasn't limited to league competition. Under Nash and Woodhouse, Blue Star also enjoyed the deepest Emirates FA Cup run in the club's modern history, reaching the Second Round Qualifying for the first time, while several young players were handed opportunities to develop, including academy graduate Jack Daley, who would later earn a professional contract with Middlesbrough.

It was a period that established Blue Star as one of the North East's most exciting clubs - and laid the foundations for many of the players now wearing green and white.

A Familiar Pathway

Saturday's fixture is a reminder of just how closely connected the two clubs have become.
No fewer than 13 members of the current Blyth Spartans squad have represented Newcastle Blue Star during their careers.

Michael Hogan, Jordan Summerly, Jack Walker, Spencer Ashcroft, Harry Barclay, Zach Simpson, Paul Van-Zandvliet, Rio Joisce, Paul Dudgeon, Kuba Zmich, Nathan Kidd, Dan Lanning and Liam Clavering have all featured for Blue Star before making the journey to Croft Park.

For some, Blue Star provided an opportunity to develop their game. For others, it became the platform from which they earned the chance to represent one of the region's most historic football clubs.

Few illustrate that pathway better than Dan Lanning.

Having established himself as one of the Northern League's most prolific forwards, Lanning arrived at Blyth this summer after scoring an outstanding 118 goals in 179 appearances for Blue Star, earning a reputation as one of the division's most feared strikers.

Paul Dudgeon's journey followed a similar path.

The midfielder took his first steps into senior football under Marc Nash at Blue Star, making around 70 appearances and helping the club reach the Northern League Division One play-off final before joining Blyth Spartans ahead of last season.

Looking back, Dudgeon believes his spell at Blue Star was fundamental to his development.
"Blue Star was very important for me. Nashy brought me into Blue Star when I was still at the Blyth academy and gave me the opportunity to step into senior football. I made around 70 appearances during my time there and it really helped me get used to men's football. It was a massive part of my development."

His relationship with Nash and Woodhouse ultimately made the move to Croft Park an easy decision.

"I've been with Nashy since I was 16 and I've always had a really good relationship with him and Woody. They've always pushed me to improve as much as they can, so as soon as I had the opportunity to work with them again, it was a no-brainer for me."

Connections Both Ways

The relationship between the clubs is far from one-sided.

Last season alone, Blue Star trio Andy Evans, Danny Anderson and Euan Potts all featured for Blyth Spartans, highlighting the movement of players between the two clubs in recent years.
Blue Star's current squad also includes a player well known to the Croft Park faithful.

Sean Reid remains fondly remembered by Spartans supporters after playing a key role during one of the club's most successful modern eras.

Standing in the opposite dugout, meanwhile, is another familiar name.

Blue Star manager Paul Brayson enjoyed a prolific spell in green and white between 2009 and 2011, scoring an outstanding 59 goals in just 77 appearances and cementing his place among the club's modern goalscoring greats.

These connections ensure Saturday's fixture carries significance far beyond the Emirates FA Cup itself.

History in the Making

Although Saturday marks the first competitive meeting between the current incarnations of Blyth Spartans and Newcastle Blue Star, history tells a slightly broader story.

The clubs did meet in a behind-closed-doors training fixture in September 2022, while Saturday will also represent the tenth competitive fixture involving a team bearing the Newcastle Blue Star name.

The most recent came back in March 2009, when Spartans were narrowly beaten 2-1 in a Northumberland Senior Cup semi-final against the Kingston Park-based Blue Star side.
Those previous meetings may belong to history, but this weekend offers an opportunity to write a new chapter.

More Than a Cup Tie

There is something fitting about the Emirates FA Cup producing this occasion.

It is a competition built on stories, and few opening-round ties can boast as many intertwined narratives as Saturday's meeting at Croft Park.

Former teammates will become opponents.

Managers will face a club they helped transform.

Players who shared dressing rooms will compete for a place in the next round.

The respect between the clubs remains evident, but once the referee's whistle sounds, sentiment will disappear.

For Blyth Spartans, the objective is simple: begin the 2026/27 competitive campaign in the best possible way and continue the club's proud FA Cup tradition.

For Newcastle Blue Star, the opportunity to create another landmark moment in their modern rise awaits.

The connections between these two clubs may be stronger than ever.

For 90 minutes on Saturday afternoon, however, they'll be put firmly to one side.

Written by Isaac Kinghorn-Eastlake.